I was helping someone move some shit in Roanoke (zip 76262). I figured while I was out there I'd see what barbecue restaurants they had to offer in the area. One that came up was Bumbershoot Barbecue. Bumbershoot's isn't actually in Roanoke but is 8.3 miles 'down the road' in Argyle.
It seemed like a worthy-enough choice as out of 138 reviews there were 3 two-stars and 2 one-stars. Or conversely, out of 138 reviews there are 121 4+ stars. Again, seemed like a decent option to try.
So first of all, this place is almost damn near in the country in my opinion. It's definitely more rural than urban although there is a 'big enough' city or two within a short driving distance. It's situated among a few other restaurants/businesses off a two-lane road/highway.
This place is a trailer, like a large airstream-type trailer. But that's not where they do the smoking, I think, as I did see a smokehouse behind the trailer. There is only outdoor seating at maybe half a dozen hexagon-shaped tables with patio umbrellas in each. There is a mostly white wooden fence around half the property that it seems can be used to finger/brush paint. There is a paint station near the seating area where we saw some kids loading up to do just that.
Based on the menu, there looked to be a fairly decent selection of meats. After pondering what to get aside from my norm of sliced brisket and ribs, we were ready to order.
I veered from my normal ordering habit of "just the meats" and ordered the three-meat meal which came with two sides. I really didn't order it for the sides but more for the fact that I didn't want to order a pound of meat(s), it sucks and then I'm stuck with 3/4 lb of meat(s).
Initially I wanted pulled pork but they were out. I then asked for turkey and initially they said they were out but then told me they had some left. My friend ordered sliced brisket, ribs and brisket sausage.
Yes, there were quite a few choices but I didn't want to go too wild and waste money on things I didn't like. I think partly it was because I was thrown off when they have this long list of meats and then they say, "Oh we're out." Not a huge deal normally, but they were not even close to being busy when we visited around 4 p.m on a Saturday.
So finally, what you see here is the three-meat meal of turkey, sliced brisket, and St Louis ribs with sides of slaw and tots. They also included some buttered(?) pickles as well as carrots with jalapenos for some reason but they are not on the menu.
My friend got the tots and potato salad and his too came with the same "secret-not-on-the-menu" pickles and carrots.
Enough jib jab. Let's get to the review:
- Slaw was the worst I've had. I'm more of a traditional slaw person. You know the kind with mayo not mayo and white, purple and orange cabbage. But I will give all foods a chance. This version of slaw is completely more like a salad with cucumber slices to boot. It had no innovation, no flavor, no taste. A complete waste of money.
- Tots are very basic and mostly flavorless. They could have been Ore-Ida tater tots but even those have more seasoning. They were just sad, crispyless and bland.
- Sliced Brisket was tender. However, just like the sides, it was flavorless. There was no smoke flavor and no charred outer rim.
- St Louis Ribs were tender as well. But fairly flavorless just like the brisket.
- Turkey was tender and juicy but, I hate to say it, mostly flavorless as well.
Also one thing to note, they place their barbecue sauces (regular and spicy) on a table out in the open between the trailer and the smokehouse. It sat in the sun the entire time we were there which was about two hours. I picked up a bottle of the regular sauce and it was like someone heated it in a microwave. Not overly hot but it was pretty damn warm. I'm not sure that's a good thing for a long period of time. The ice dispenser also sits in the sun a lot depending on the time of day. I think they need to invest in some pop-up canopies.
Overall, this place wasn't as good as I thought it would be based purely on my assumption. Would I go back? Probably not since I live in North Dallas and there are already very good tasting well-established barbecue joints there. I also heard that 407 BBQ is fairly decent and down the street from Bumbershoot so I'll have to give it a try next time I'm in the middle of B.F.E.!